The NAM and 5 other business associations have asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit to review EPA's decision published July 15 to disapprove revisions to a Texas Clean Air Act implementation plan that relates to the state’s Flexible Permits
Program. The Texas plan was submitted to EPA for approval in 1994 and revised several times since then. After a recent notice-and-comment period, EPA decided that the Texas plan did not meet its requirements for a minor plan revision ("Minor NSR SIP revision") for various reasons described in its decision. Alternatively, it ruled that the plan did not meet its requirements for a substitute Major NSR SIP revision.
This petition for review is the first step in a proceeding that will eventually present the court with detailed legal issues to be resolved. The Texas flexible permits program allows operators of facilities that generate air emissions flexibility in managing their operations. While one flexible permit is allowed per plant site or account, the applicant can choose which facilities and pollutants to include. The permits allow plants to exceed pollution limits from individual emission sources as long as the facility as a whole remains below an overall emissions cap. EPA's action highlights a serious struggle between national and state environmental authorities in regulating air emissions.
Click here for further developments in this case, which has been consolidated with Texas v. EPA.